|
Development Topics
How Juvenile Violence Begins
Human Nature
There are primarily
two schools of thought on human nature that we will consider. One argues that
"evil" does not emanate from within, but primarily from outside a person. This
understanding has several implications:
- A person's behavior
is largely determined by his social environment; i.e., the influence of the
media, weapon availability, human relations, poverty, etc.
Religion is a powerful force in regulating behavior.
|
- To eliminate
bad or evil behavior, one must focus on changing the social forces rather
than on an individual's actions.
- If a person
is not exposed to negative social forces, he will not be prone to evil behavior.
He "naturally" has "good" desires and therefore "good" behavior.
- Individuals
share the responsibility for their actions with the social forces around them.
Because of the
tremendous influence that the Judeo-Christian ethic has had on it, Western civilization
has generally accepted a different view: that there are evil actions and evil
people, and that evil ultimately emanates from human nature. There are a number
of implications of this understanding of human nature as well:
- Individuals
are responsible for their actions, and a person's behavior is, for the most
part, acted out volitionally.
- One can choose
negative behavior without being influenced by negative outside forces at all.
One can also choose "good" behavior even when exposed to evil social forces.
- Outside forces
certainly have an influence on a person's behavior, but in the end, it is
the individual who chooses whether to act upon an evil desire.
- One must be
taught what is good behavior and what is not, and he must restrain evil behavior.
We may well see more juveniles acting out in ways that shock our sense.
|
This latter view
seems to be most consistent with experience. Clearly, there are many people,
young and old, who are exposed to "negative" social influences yet have "good"
behavior, primarily as a result of a value system they have been taught. Simple
observation of very young children shows that even before they are exposed to
negative social forces, they can be selfish, challenge authority, be hurtful
and sometimes even be harmful to those around them. It is up to adults to teach
children good behavior.
As any parent will
testify, bad behavior seems to come as naturally as the good in a young child.
It goes without saying that outside forces play an important role in influencing
one's behavior, as this paper will argue below. But a person's value system,
or "inward" beliefs, primarily determines his or her behavior.
This helps explain
why religion is such a powerful force in regulating behavior. Religion's focus
on an individual's choosing a new or different moral value system, validates
the view that "inward" change results in outward change, in spite of a negative
social environment.
Garbarino says
that even in the worst social environments, many of the violent juveniles whom
he has interviewed have undergone dramatic inward, moral transformations; changes
that have trumped both family instability and a socially toxic environment:
Many of the
boys and men I know found the starting point for that path back from violence
through spiritual exploration. Each replaced the ugliness in his life with
spiritual beauty. Each of these individuals began seeking answers to the psychological
challenges of traumatic experiences in human development. Their path led to
and through the unconscious to the spiritual, and ultimately to the light
of spiritual freedom … the success of spiritual exploration in the lives of
lost boys is one reason why spiritual literacy should be a part of educational
programs for boys at risk.1
A world without
meaning, a world composed only of fact and figures, is a world of despair to
which some young people will react destructively - and as we have witnessed,
sometimes violently. Until we recognize the essential role that spirituality
plays in providing hope and purpose for young people, we may well see more juveniles
acting out in ways that shock our senses, but confirm their outlook on life.
—John C. Thomas
Endnotes: 1Dr. James Garbarino, Lost Boys: Why Our Sons Turn Violent and How We Can Save Them, (New York: The Free Press), 1999.
Adapted from "The Root Causes of Juvenile Violence."
Copyright © 1999 Focus on the Family.
All rights reserved. International copyright secured.
Do you have thoughts, questions, advice on this topic? Post your stories and comments in the forum for other parents to respond to. Enter the forum now.
|
 |
|